The Imposter at the Helm: A New Leader’s Guide to Conquering Self-Doubt

The Imposter at the Helm: A New Leader’s Guide to Conquering Self-Doubt

The ascent to a leadership position is often a coronation accompanied by a silent shadow – imposter syndrome. This psychological phenomenon casts a long shadow of self-doubt, where individuals, despite their qualifications and accomplishments, struggle to internalise their success and believe they are undeserving of their achievements. 

For new leaders, this internal imposter can be particularly disruptive, hindering their confidence and impacting their effectiveness.

However, imposter syndrome is not a personal failing; it’s a common experience shared by high achievers across industries. The good news is that by understanding the mechanisms of this syndrome and adopting strategic coping mechanisms, new leaders can silence the inner critic and embrace their leadership potential.

Unveiling the Imposter –  Recognising the Symptoms:

Imposter syndrome manifests in a variety of ways, but some common symptoms include:

  • The Persistent Undercurrent of Self-Doubt: New leaders may find themselves questioning their abilities and decisions, wondering if they are “good enough” for the role. They might compare themselves to others, often focusing on perceived shortcomings and neglecting their own strengths. This constant self-criticism can be paralysing, hindering their ability to make decisions and take action.
  • Discounting Achievements – A Familiar Foe: Even after achieving success, new leaders may downplay their accomplishments. They might attribute their victories to luck, external factors, or the work of others. This undermines their sense of self-efficacy and fuels feelings of inadequacy. A promotion, for instance, might be attributed to being “in the right place at the right time” rather than a recognition of their skills and hard work.
  • The Fear of Exposure –  A Paralysing Threat: The fear of being “found out” as a fraud can be a powerful motivator. New leaders may avoid taking risks or showcasing their expertise, fearing that any mistakes will confirm their self-perceived incompetence. This can lead to a reluctance to delegate tasks, a fear of public speaking, and an overall hesitation to step into their leadership role fully.
  • The Perfectionist Trap – A Pathway to Anxiety:  New leaders may hold themselves to unreasonably high standards, striving for unattainable perfection. This relentless pursuit of flawlessness leads to anxiety and can hinder their ability to learn and grow. They might avoid taking on new challenges or implementing innovative ideas for fear of making mistakes.

Silencing the Inner Critic – Strategies for New Leaders

While imposter syndrome can be your enemy, new leaders can equip themselves with strategies to navigate its challenges and emerge as confident and effective leaders:

  • Acknowledge and Normalise the Experience: The first step towards overcoming imposter syndrome is acknowledging its presence.  Knowing that it’s a common experience can be incredibly validating and help new leaders feel less alone. Sharing their struggles with trusted colleagues or mentors can foster a sense of camaraderie and understanding.
  • Focus on Facts, Not Feelings: Self-doubt often stems from emotional responses rather than a realistic assessment of skills and experience. New leaders can combat this by creating a record of their accomplishments – this could be a list of completed projects, positive feedback received, or skills they have mastered. Grounding themselves in facts fosters a more objective perspective and boosts self-confidence.
  • Reframe Self-Talk – Challenging the Inner Critic: The inner critic is often relentless. New leaders can counter its negativity by practising positive self-talk. Instead of dwelling on shortcomings, they can challenge negative thoughts and replace them with affirmations that acknowledge their strengths and capabilities. Reminding themselves of past successes can be a powerful way to counter feelings of inadequacy.
  • Embrace Learning and Growth – Mistakes as Stepping Stones: Mistakes and setbacks are inevitable – they are learning opportunities. New leaders can reframe challenges as a chance to develop new skills and refine their approach. This growth mindset allows them to learn from experience and build resilience. Instead of fearing mistakes, they can view them as opportunities to learn and grow as leaders.
  • Seek Support and Mentorship –  Building a Network of Allies: Imposter syndrome can thrive in isolation. New leaders can build a support network of trusted colleagues, mentors, or coaches who can provide encouragement, guidance, and objective feedback. Sharing their experiences with others who understand the challenges can be a powerful antidote to self-doubt.
  • Celebrate Successes – Big Wins and Small Victories: Downplaying achievements only reinforces the imposter narrative. New leaders should take the time to acknowledge and celebrate their successes, both big and small.  Taking a moment to appreciate their accomplishments, whether it’s completing a project or leading a successful team meeting, reinforces a sense of accomplishment and boosts confidence.
The Executive Ascent: How Professional Coaching Empowers Senior Leadership in an Ever-Changing Business LandscapeThe Executive Ascent: How Professional Coaching Empowers Senior Leadership in an Ever-Changing Business Landscape
Manchester United. What are their secrets to productivity?What is this the best way to measure productivity?

Subscribe to our Podcast

Hosted by our very own Ben Stocken and Benjamin Wade our ‘How They Lead’ podcast aims to evolve the way people perform in leadership roles by showcasing a variety of high performance interviews with people from Patrick Kershaw from The RAF Red Arrows to CEO’s like Steve Phillips who help large brands like Pepsi, Mars and Unilever.

Get one step ahead – Click below to subscribe.

Ben Stocken and Ben Wade